Ms. Ref. No.: APCATB-D-16-01948R2
Title: Sandwich-structured CeO2@ZSM-5 hybrid composites for catalytic oxidation of 1, 2-dichloroethane: An integrated solution to coking and chlorine poisoning deactivation
Applied Catalysis B: Environmental
Dear Prof. Dai:
I am pleased to inform you that your manuscript, entitled "Sandwich-structured CeO2@ZSM-5 hybrid composites for catalytic oxidation of 1, 2-dichloroethane: An integrated solution to coking and chlorine poisoning deactivation", is now accepted for publication in Applied Catalysis B.
这篇文章一波三折,终于接受。
初审意见很好,两个接受(其中一个Reviewer #3: I think the paper is nice now after revisions and can be accepted as it is.这篇文章在送审之前已经按照编辑的要求做了大量的改动和数据、内容的增加),但是有一个拒稿,理由是催化剂活性不高、与我们之前的文章可能有重复(但实际上完全没有Nanoscale. 2016 May 14;8(18):9621-8. doi: 10.1039/c6nr01800a. Epub 2016 Apr 22.
Sandwich-like PdO/CeO2 nanosheet@HZSM-5 membrane hybrid composite for methane combustion: self-redispersion, sintering-resistance and oxygen, water-tolerance.
Dai Q1, Bai S, Lou Y, Wang X, Guo Y, Lu G.
Author information)。花了大量文字解释两篇文章的不同
二审编辑又找了一个审稿人,说也要对审稿人2做出回复,于是又大量文字解释
对于这篇文章看得出编辑费了一番心
评论 (0)