来客网

丘成桐自己在威海的报告中亲口证明庆杰和田刚不是抄袭

声明:本文转载自 「科技时空」, 或因排版与篇幅原因进行过编辑,内容未经本站独立核实,不代表本站立场、观点或建议。 如涉及版权问题,请联系我们,核实后立即删除。 [ 免责声明 ]

下面有人贴出丘成桐在威海的报告,以此来说明庆杰和田刚的抄袭证据确凿,可是认真读了一下,却发现丘成桐自己已经清楚地说了庆杰和田刚不是抄袭。

现在来仔细看一下关键段落:

In the above theorem of Huisken-Yau, the uniqueness of foliationis true in a neighborhood of infinity whose size depends on thechoice of both foliations. This is good enough for defining centerof mass which is the key purpose of the foliation. They alsoproposed to enlarge the neighborhood for uniqueness of level setswith constant mean curvature so that it depends only on the choiceof one foliation. While it has some interest, it has little to dowith the above applications in general relativity. This proposalwas observed to be true (Qing-Tian) based basically on the sameargument of Huisken-Yau and a simple integral for-mula.

按照这一段,Huisken-Yau的结果说the uniqueness of foliationis true in a neighborhood of infinity whose size depends on thechoice of both foliations. 他们在文章中也建议enlarge the neighborhood for uniqueness of level setswith constant mean curvature so that it depends only on the choiceof one foliation. 最后丘成桐亲口说:This proposalwas observed to be true (Qing-Tian) based basically on the sameargument of Huisken-Yau and a simple integral for-mula.

从这里可以看出,丘成桐非常明确地说Huisken-Yau提出了一个建议,而庆杰和田刚用了和Huisken-Yau相同的论证和一个积分公式实现了Huisken-Yau的建议。

显然,丘成桐对庆杰和田刚这个工作评价很差,因为问题和想法是Huisken-Yau建议的,证明方法和Huisken-Yau的相同,除此之外所需要用的一个积分公式也很简单。

当然,庆杰和田刚并不同意这样的说法,比如,对丘成桐认为论证方法相同,他们指出:

In [HY], a global estimate was sought after (cf. Lemma 5.6

in [HY]), with a compromise to assume that the inner radiusis not smaller than H^{−q} for q > 1/2 . They stated in theparagraph after Theorem 5.1 (page 21, [HY]) that theirassumption on inner radius “seems to be optimal froma technical point of view”. While in this paper we dodifferent estimates in three different scales.Particularly we establish some decay estimate for theintermediate scales by using an asymptoticanalysis developed in [QT].

但现在让我们退一万步,暂时假定丘成桐所说为真,我们可以看到丘成桐自己亲口说庆杰和田刚做到了他们所建议去做的事情。而且还用了一个他们所没有的积分公式。

当然,如果有人在自己文章提到可以做什么事情,一般的规矩还是不会去做,因为这个理论是作者发展出来的,既然作者说可以怎么做,

旁人是应该让作者自己去写下来,除非是十年八年也写不出来,在和作者交涉仍然没有看到任何写下来的东西后,他人在给了原作者足够多的credit后也是可以做的。可是在这个case中,一方面Huisken-Yau已经将whether stable constantmean curvature surfaces are actually completely unique outside afixed compact set作为一个open question提出,另一方面,距离他们这篇文章写作的时间也已经有十年了。这种情况下,庆杰和田刚绝对可以去做这个问题。

其实这个问题可以争论的是究竟有没有意义,这一套理论基本上是为了做经典广义相对论中而发展起来的,既然广义相对论中的应用只需要Huisken-Yau的唯一性结果,这个更好一点的唯一性结果可能意义的确不大。但即使丘成桐自己在上面所引段落中也说it has some interest。既然庆杰和田刚实现了Huisken-Yau十年前的一个建议,回答了他们十年前的一个open question,而这个唯一性结果按照丘成桐自己的说法也 has some interest,显然和抄袭连边都沾不上了。

另外要指出的是,贴出丘成桐威海报告的人摘录了庆杰和田刚的一段和Huisken-Yau文章中的一段。可是从这两段就可以看出庆杰和田刚的唯一性和Huisken-Yau的不一样。庆杰和田刚说:

In this note we show that indeed on an asymptotically flat3-manifold with positive mass there is a unique foliation ofstable spheres of constant mean curvature near the end.

而Huisken-Yau说:

In this section we will show that the foliation$\{M_\sigma\}$ constructed in Theorem 3.1 and Theorem 4.1 isunique. In fact, we show that the individual surfaces $M_\sigma$are the only stable constant mean curvature surfaces outside asmall interior region of $N$.

显然这是两个不同的statements,不知道摘录出来怎么证明抄袭?不过摘录时没有把Huisken-Yau文章中接下去的关键段落摘录出来,这里我来摘录一下吧:

In this section we will show that the foliation {M_\sigma}onstructed in Theorem 3.1 and Theorem 4.1 is unique. In fact, weshow that the individual surfaces M_\sigma are the only stableconstant mean curvature surfaces outside a small interiorregion of N.

5.1 Theorem. Let m > 0 and 1/2 0depending only on m�^{-1}; q and C_0 such that for all 0 1/2 seems to be optimal from a technical point of view,but it is an open question whether stable constant mean curvature surfaces areactually completely unique outside a fixed compact set. The stability assumptionis only used to derive curvature estimates and can be discarded if only surfacesare considered where the principal curvatures are comparable to (1/2)H.

------------------------------------------

这里是指责田刚抄袭的原帖:

田刚抄袭证据确凿

The following paragraphs come from Yau's talk in Weihai in theoccasion of the seventieth anniversary of the Chinese MathematicsSociety.\\

{\sl For surfaces with constant mean curvature, we have theconcept of stability. (Fixing the volume it encloses, the secondvariation of area is non-negative.) Making use of my works oneigenvalues with Peter Li, Christodoulou and I proved that theHawking mass of these surfaces is positive. This fact was used byHuisken and I to prove uniqueness and existence of foliation byconstant mean curvature spheres for a three dimensionalasymptotically flat manifold with positive mass. After ten years,Tian and Qing reproduced our uniqueness result, but the argumentis basically the same.

This foliation was used by Huisken and Yau to give a canonical coordinate system at infinity. It defines the concept of center of gravity whereimportant properties for general relativity are found. The mostnotable is that total linear momentum is equal to the total massmultiple with the velocity of the center of mass. One expects tofind good asymptotic properties of the tensors in generalrelativity along these canonical surfaces. We hope to find a gooddefinition of angular momentum based on this concept of center ofgravity so that global inequality like total mass can dominate thesquare norm of angular momentum.

In the above theorem of Huisken-Yau, the uniqueness of foliationis true in a neighborhood of infinity whose size depends on thechoice of both foliations. This is good enough for defining centerof mass which is the key purpose of the foliation. They alsoproposed to enlarge the neighborhood for uniqueness of level setswith constant mean curvature so that it depends only on the choiceof one foliation. While it has some interest, it has little to dowith the above applications in general relativity. This proposalwas observed to be true (Qing-Tian) based basically on the sameargument of Huisken-Yau and a simple integral xxxxula.}\\

Note on page 2 of the paper of Qing-Tian(arXiv:math.DG/0506005 v1 Jun 2005), They claim:\\

{\sl In this note we show that indeed on an asymptotically flat3-manifold with positive mass there is a unique foliation ofstable spheres of constant mean curvature near the end.} \\

This statement can be found on page 301 of Huisken-Yau (Invent.Math. {\bf 124}(1996), 281-311):\\

{\sl In this section we will show that the foliation$\{M_\sigma\}$ constructed in Theorem 3.1 and Theorem 4.1 isunique. In fact, we show that the individual surfaces $M_\sigma$are the only stable constant mean curvature surfaces outside asmall interior region of $N$.}

评论 (0)