来客网

Dr.Si's Western Blot[英文]

声明:本文转载自 「教育园地」, 或因排版与篇幅原因进行过编辑,内容未经本站独立核实,不代表本站立场、观点或建议。 如涉及版权问题,请联系我们,核实后立即删除。 [ 免责声明 ]

For some reason, I cannot login as "Immunologist" on XYS, I cannot post any messages there at all either. So I post my article here and e-mail a copy to "lijun"'s mailbox (the address he has posted on XYS). Hopefully, "lijun" will post the message on XYS for me.

教育园地won't let me use "Immunologist" it's "too long". so here I am:"Immunity"

Re: Dr.Si’s Western Blot

Dear Si,

I came across your article on XYS this morning and the western blot picture attached with it drew my attention. First, let me say that I have no intension to offend you. I know I am in no position to make a judgment or conclusion on the dispute between you and Dr.Wei. You are at least one generation ahead of me. You probably started to work on science before I could even spell “science” correctly. Actually, I respect the courage that you have shown in your letters. However, I’d like to make a few comments on the western blot result you posted today, which in your opinion, is one of the critical evidences of your accusation.

Your group immunized mice with HUVEC, and used the antiserum for the blot. Your group found multiple bands instead of several major bands as Dr.Wei reported in his paper, so together with other clues, you reasoned that Dr.Wei’s result is suspicious. However, even as a non-western blot expert, I can argue with you that there are some frauds in the logic. You may have realized it by yourself already that there are numerous variables in the system: 1) HUVEC cells. HUVEC are primary cultures, isolation method, source, culture conditions and passage numbers could change their characters; 2) sample preparation method. I forgot the details. Did you (and Dr.Wei) use cell extract or the whole cells? Different preparation method will give different results 3) immunization doses and routes 4) Primary antibodies, you and Dr.Wei used different preparations 5) secondary antibodies 6) exposure time. The longer the exposure is, the more bands you are going to see 7) it looks like the membranes have been cut and putted together from the picture you posted. Was the control done simultaneously with the samples?

Based on the above said reasons, I hope that I have convinced you that your western blot result should not be included as evidence at all.

Dr.Si, if you have questions or comments, please contact me.. If you prefer not to discuss this in public, please drop me a line at [email protected]. I will check the mailbox at least once every other day. I‘d also like to limit the discussion in the scientific community in a scientific manner as well. Thank you.

Respectfully yours,

Immunologist

P.S.: Dr.Fang, if you happen to see this message, could you post it next to Dr.Si’s Western Blot on your website? As far as I can tell, there are a lot of students among your readers. Some of them may find the above information on western blot useful for their experiments in the real life. Thanks.

评论 (0)