来客网

RNA诺贝尔奖:周芷和萝卜丝谁的贡献大?

声明:本文转载自 「科教论坛」, 或因排版与篇幅原因进行过编辑,内容未经本站独立核实,不代表本站立场、观点或建议。 如涉及版权问题,请联系我们,核实后立即删除。 [ 免责声明 ]

1977年,冷泉港实验室分别由Louis T. Chow和Richard J. Roberts领导的两个实验室合作,发表一片《细胞》,周为第一作者,萝卜丝为最后作者,发现RNA剪接现象。同年,MIT的Philip Sharp 和他的博后发表一片《PNAS》,得到同一发现。

1993年,萝卜丝和夏普共享诺贝尔奖。

这个奖为什么萝卜丝得了,周芷没得?

首要原因,是冷泉港实验室主任花生挺萝卜丝,压周芷。花生是周和萝卜的顶头上司,还是DNA发现者,分子生物学之父。外人当然听花生的。

萝卜自己的说法是:我已经研究腺病毒RNA了,是我请周用她的电镜技术专长来做一个实验。这种说法,目的是强调萝卜出主意,周做具体技术。所以,萝卜应该得奖。

萝卜从来不敢说清楚他们的合作。因为,事实不是这样。

事实是怎么回事呢?

萝卜的特长是做限制性内切酶。

周是做电镜。但是那时,电镜对RNA剪接的发现是一个关键技术。MIT的夏普也需要靠电镜,才能证明他们自己的发现。

萝卜还占了一个便宜:周在1977年有两片《细胞》,八月那片,是周自己实验室做的,没有那个得奖的萝卜丝(RJ Roberts),里面有一丝萝卜,但那是JM Roberts。八月这片《细胞》已经显示了RNA剪接:关键的发现,八月的《细胞》已经有了,它已经说,同一个DNA转录产生多个RNA,这些RNA长度不同,却有相同的5’端和3’端。它还证明,RNA对应于DNA的不相连片断。所以,这片周实验室的论文,已经发现RNA剪接。

周和萝卜丝合作的《细胞》,是九月份发表的。它比八月的,仔细一点。但是,突破不是这片论文。

很多人,没有仔细看八月的《细胞》,以为,那片论文的JM Roberts和九月的RJ Roberts是同一个人。因此以为,两片论文都是周和萝卜丝合作的结晶。让萝卜丝蒙混过关。

周和萝卜谁贡献大,一目了然。

在这样的事实面前,华人不为华人说话,那可是自虐。

这两片论文,都可以下载全文。

摘要就很清楚:

A map of cytoplasmic RNA transcripts from lytic adenovirus type 2, determined by electron microscopy of RNA:DNA hybrids.Cell. 1977 Aug;11(4):819-36.

We have used electron microscopic RNA loop mapping to determine, to within 200 nucleotides,the chromosome coordinates of the 5’ and 3’ ends of adenovirus type 2 trancripts isolated from the cytoplasm of productively infected human KB cells. The major blocks of trancription and many of the individual transcripts have discrete lengths and well defined 5’ and 3’ termini. Early cytoplasmic RNA is transcribed from four separate regions of the adenovirus genome, in map intervals 1.3-11.1, 62.4-67.9, 78.6-86.1 and 91.5-96.8. The most frequent late RNA loop occurred between coordinates 51.9 and 62.2. A late trancript complementary to interval 86.3-91.5 formed a characteristic R loop with a long branch of displaced RNA from coordinate 89.8-91.5, possibly a resultof secondary structure near coordinate 89.8. Other late cytoplasmic RNA loops were locatedbetween coordinates 11.1 and 14.9, and in the intervals from 30-52 and 68- 83. Trancripts fromseveral regions of the chromosome had variable lengths but common 5’ or 3’ termini. Few R loopswere seen between map coordinates 15 and 30. Switches between template strands were observedat map positions 11.2,62.4 and 91.5. Many of the R loops have been correlated with geneproducts mapped previously by translation of RNA complementary to different portions of thechromosome.

Chow LT, Gelinas RE, Broker TR, Roberts RJ.An amazing sequence arrangement at the 5' ends of adenovirus 2 messenger RNA.Cell. 1977 Sep;12(1):1-8.

The 5' terminal sequences of several adenovirus 2 (Ad2) mRNAs, isolated late in infection, are complementary to sequences within the Ad2 genome which are remote from the DNA from which the main coding sequence of each mRNA is transcribed. This has been observed by forming RNA displacement loops (R loops) between Ad2 DNA and unfractionated polysomal RNA from infected cells. The 5' terminal sequences of mRNAs in R loops, variously located between positions 36 and 92, form complex secondary hybrids with single-stranded DNA from restriction endonuclease fragments containing sequences to the left of position 36 on the Ad2 genome. The structures visualized in the electron microscope show that short sequences coded at map positions 16.6, 19.6 and 26.6 on the R strand are joined to form a leader sequence of 150-200 nucleotides at the 5' end of many late mRNAs. A late mRNA which maps to the left of position 16.6 shows a different pattern of second site hybridization. It contains sequences from 4.9-6.0 linked directly to those from 9.6-10.9. These findings imply a new mechanism for the biosynthesis of Ad2 mRNA in mammalian cells.

评论 (0)