Conjectures No More?
Consensus forming on the Proofof the Poincaré andGeometrization Conjectures
Allyn Jackson
(Allyn Jackson is senior writer and deputy editor of theNotices. Her email address is [email protected].)
完整pdf 版本:http://www.ams.org/notices/200608/comm-perelman.pdf
Have the Poincaré Conjecture and the Thurston Geometrization Conjecture been proved?This question has been on the minds of mathematiciansfor more than three years, ever since Grigory Perelman posted his now-famous paper son the Web. In mid summer 2006, as the International Congress of Mathematicians in Madrid approachesand speculation about the Fields Medalsis buzzing, some experts who had been makingcautious statements for the past three years soundincreasingly confident that the conjectures arefinally yielding. In particular, many believe thePoincaré Conjecture is now a bona fide theorem.The picture is slightly less clear for the GeometrizationConjecture, but there is much optimism thatthis result will soon be established as well.
Of the Dollars and the Glory
For mathematicians, the million dollars that the Clay Mathematics Institute (CMI) has offered for thesolution of the Poincaré Conjecture is mere icingon the cake. The real prize is the glory of settlinga question that has tantalized mathematicians formore than a century. The statement dates back to1904, when Henri Poincaré conjectured that it isthe property of being simply connected that topologicallydistinguishes the three-sphere from othercompact three-manifolds. Since that time therehave been many incorrect attempts to prove thePoincaré Conjecture, some of them by such wellknownmathematicians as Edwin Moise, Christos Papakyriakopolous, Valentin Poenaru, and Colin Rourke. A recent incorrect proof, by Martin Dunwoodyof Southampton University, came in 2002,about six months before Perelman posted his firstpaper on the subject. Almost as soon as news storiesstarted to appear about Dunwoody’s proof (anApril 2002 article in the New York Times carriedthe headline “UK Math Wiz May Have Solved Problem”),the proof fell apart.
In fact, there have been so many wrong proofsof the Poincaré Conjecture that John Stallings ofthe University of California, Berkeley, has postedon his webpage a paper he wrote in 1966 called“How not to prove the Poincaré Conjecture”, whichdescribes his own failed attack, as a warning to otherswho might hit upon the same idea. One characteristicthat most of the failed attempts share isa reliance on topological arguments. But, notedJohn Morgan of Columbia University, “It seemslike this problem does not succumb to that typeof argument.” Rather, he said, one needs toolsfrom outside topology, from geometry and analysis,to tackle this topological question.
In contrast to the multiple failed attempts onPoincaré, it appears that, before Perelman's workappeared, no one had seriously claimed to be ableto prove the full Thurston Geometrization Conjecture.In fact, this is a much deeper and more farreachingstatement than the Poincaré Conjectureand includes Poincaré as a special case. First proposedin the 1970s by William Thurston, who is nowat Cornell University, the Geometrization Conjectureprovides a way to classify all three-manifolds.Thurston’s great insight was to see how geometrycould be used to understand the topology ofthree-manifolds. The Geometrization Conjecturestates that any three-manifold can be split intopieces in an essentially unique way and that eachof these pieces carries a geometric structure givenby one of eight model geometries. The conjecturewas not wide open before the work of Perelman; ithad been established in many cases. Thurston himselfproved the conjecture for manifolds that aresufficiently large. Several mathematicians contributedto establishing the full conjecture for sixof the eight geometries. The two remaining geometriesare the spherical and hyperbolic ones, wherethe metrics have constant positive and constantnegative curvature, respectively. The Poincaré Conjecturecomes under the case of metrics of constantpositive curvature. (An excellent historical accountis [Milnor].)
Against this background, mathematicians werenaturally skeptical when Perelman posted his articleson the arXiv, the first in November 2002, thesecond in March 2003, and the third in July 2003[Perelman1–3]. Nevertheless, his efforts were fromthe outset taken quite seriously. One reason is thatPerelman is a well-regarded mathematician who hadalready made distinguished contributions to geometricanalysis. He was an invited speaker at the1994 ICM in Zurich, where he gave a lecture in thegeometry section about spaces with curvaturebounded below. In 1996 he was awarded one of theten prizes given to outstanding young mathematiciansevery four years by the European MathematicalSociety (Perelman refused to accept thatprize).
Another reason Perelman’s work was taken seriouslyis that it fits into a well-known program touse the Ricci flow to prove the GeometrizationConjecture. The originator of this program isRichard Hamilton, now at Columbia University,who will be a plenary speaker at the 2006 ICM inMadrid. The abstract for Hamilton’s talk says thatthe Ricci flow program was developed by him andShing-Tung Yau of Harvard University. The idea,first described in a 1982 paper by Hamilton [Hamilton],is to use the Ricci flow, a partial differentialequation that is a nonlinear version of the heatequation, to homogenize the geometry of threemanifoldsto show that they fit into Thurston’sclassification. It was generally believed that, philosophically,Hamilton’s approach ought to work.This belief strengthened as Hamilton and othersworked out much of the analysis that was needed.The toughest obstacle was handling the singularitiesthat could develop in the Ricci flow. It was thisobstacle that Perelman, by introducing deep newideas in geometric analysis, was able to overcometo such spectacular effect. (An excellent expositoryaccount about the Ricci flow is [Anderson].)
Poring over Perelman
In the spring of 2003, after his first two papers hadappeared on the Web, Perelman gave lecturesat several universities in the U.S., includingColumbia University, the Massachusetts Instituteof Technology, and Princeton University, as well asa series of lectures at Stony Brook University. Soonthereafter he returned to his home base inSt. Petersburg, and he has given only a very fewlectures on the subject since then. He answeredmathematical questions by email, but some mathematiciansreport that after a while he stoppedeven that form of communication. It is not clearwhat Perelman has made of the acclaim that hassurrounded his achievements. Many articles abouthis work have come out in the popular press, thoughit appears that he never consented to be interviewedby reporters.
As mathematicians began to read the paperscarefully, they found them tough going. “Perelman’sarticles are remarkably carefully written ifone takes into account how much new ground hebreaks in a relatively few number of pages,” explainedJohn Lott of the University of Michigan.“However, they are not written in such a way thatone can just sit down and quickly decide whetherhis arguments are complete.” Morgan remarkedthat Perelman omits certain technicalities thatturned out to be standard, but rather tricky, towork out in detail. And, Morgan said, sometimesarguments are justified by a statement that theyare analogous to arguments presented earlier, butit is not always clear exactly how the earlier argumentscan be adapted. On top of these difficulties,there are some outright mistakes in the paper,though none has proven serious. It appears thatPerelman never submitted his articles to any journal.Had he done so, they probably would not havebeen accepted without substantial revisions.
Soon after Perelman’s papers appeared on theWeb, mathematicians undertook efforts to understandand verify them. In June 2003 Lott, togetherwith Bruce Kleiner, who is now at Yale University,started a webpage in which they presented notesabout Perelman’s work as they went carefullythrough his papers. In late 2003 the AmericanInstitute of Mathematics in Palo Alto and the MathematicalSciences Research Institute in Berkeleyjointly sponsored a workshop on Perelman’s firstarticle; another workshop, about Perelman’s secondarticle, was held in the summer of 2004 at PrincetonUniversity. The Clay Institute, which has anobvious interest in knowing whether Perelman’swork is correct, provided funding for the Princetonworkshop and also sponsored a month-longsummer school held at MSRI in the summer of2005. In addition Clay provided some support toKleiner and Lott, who continued to add to and posttheir notes on the Web, as well as Morgan andGang Tian of Princeton University, who are collaboratingon a book about Perelman’s work on thePoincaré Conjecture.
In June 2005 Gérard Besson of the University ofGrenoble presented a Bourbaki lecture on the workof Perelman; the lecture will appear in the Astérisqueseries in September 2006. In the fall of 2005 Xi-PingZhu of Zhongshan University gave a six-monthseries of lectures at Harvard University, describingthe content of a paper that he has written with Huai-Dong Cao of Lehigh University and that appearedin the June 2006 issue of the Asian Journal of Mathematics.There have been other workshops andsummer schools on the subject, not to mention themany lectures given in mathematics departmentsand at conferences. Study groups were submitted to go through Perelman’s papers in several countries,including China, France, Germany, and the UnitedStates.
While it seems that Perelman’s papers werenever refereed in the traditional sense, they havebeen subjected to extraordinary scrutiny in thethree and a half years since their posting on theWeb. The simple passage of time without anyonefinding a serious problem in his work has, at leastfor many nonexperts, led to a conviction that itmust be correct. For example, Koji Fujiwara of TohokuUniversity is not an expert in this area, buthe believes Perelman’s work must be right, for tworeasons. “If there were something philosophicallywrong, so that the approach could not work, afterthree years someone would have found the philosophicalproblem,” he reasoned. And second,Fujiwara said, Perelman is a well-known expert onRicci curvature, and his previous papers have beenreliable and have not been found to contain mistakes.Of course, this kind of confidence is theprivilege of the nonexpert. Experts have to workmuch harder.
Filling in the Details
“They should give [Perelman] a Fields Medal for thePoincaré Conjecture,” declared John Morgan in aninterview in May 2006. “I believe the argument iscorrect, as do, I think, all who have looked at it seriously.…
This is clearly the most exciting thingthat has happened in mathematics in the last fouryears,” since the previous batch of Fields Medalswere awarded. Morgan said that the book he iswriting with Tian, which is to appear in early 2007,will provide a full exposition of the proof of thePoincaré Conjecture à la Perelman.1 Morgan saidthat he has no doubts that Perelman can also provethe Geometrization Conjecture, but Morgan hasnot personally gone through that proof in detail,as he has done with Poincaré.
Indeed, many mathematicians express more confidencein the proof of Poincaré than in the proofof Geometrization. Perelman himself provided ashortcut to proving Poincaré, and there is a moreextensive body of material that is needed for theproof of the full Geometrization Conjecture. Somebelieve that the best way to ensure that Poincaréhas really been proved is to verify the proof ofGeometrization. So what is the status of the proofof the Geometrization Conjecture?
In May 2006 Kleiner and Lott posted on the arXivan article titled “Notes on Perelman’s papers”. Theysay that their article, along with a 2005 paper byT. Shioya and T. Yamaguchi, provides details forPerelman’s arguments for the GeometrizationConjecture. Lott cautioned that Perelman’s workhas to be further examined by the mathematicalcommunity before there can be any universallyaccepted verdict. The Kleiner-Lott paper is basedon the set of notes they began posting on the Webin the summer of 2003. In the three years overwhich they developed the notes and made thempublic, Kleiner and Lott received corrections andcomments from many mathematicians. They plan to submit their paper to a journal.
In late April 2006 the Asian Journal of Mathematicsannounced on its website the upcomingpublication of the paper by Cao and Zhu, “A completeproof of the Poincaré and GeometrizationConjectures—Application of the Hamilton-Perelmantheory of the Ricci flow”. The announcementincluded the paper’s abstract, which states in full:“In this paper, we give a complete proof of thePoincaré and the geometrization conjectures. Thiswork depends on the accumulative works of manygeometric analysts in the past thirty years. Thisproof should be considered as the crowningachievement of the Hamilton-Perelman theory ofRicci flow.” The 330-page paper appeared in printin the June 2006 issue of the Asian Journal. Theissue has not been made available electronically onthe journal’s website and is available only as aprinted paper publication. The Cao-Zhu article didnot circulate as a preprint, but the work presentedthere was described in Zhu’s lectures at Harvardduring the 2005–2006 academic year.
Some have noted the short amount of time betweenthe submission date for the Cao-Zhu paper,December 12, 2005, and the date when it was acceptedfor publication, April 16, 2006, and wondered whether such an important paper of over 300 pages could have been refereed in a serious way.In a May 2006 interview, Yau, who is one of the editors-in-chief of the Asian Journal, said that theman uform had been around for a year, but “wehave been very careful not to distribute it, to makesure everything is right before it is in print.” Askedwhether the paper had been refereed in the usualway, Yau said that it had and remarked that theAsian Journal has very high standards.
Although not enough time has yet passed for the Cao-Zhu paper to have been subjected to muchscrutiny by the mathematical community, the paper became widely known because of coverage aboutit in the Chinese press during June 2006. “ChineseMathematicians Solve Global Puzzle” read the headlineof an article that appeared on the Xinhua newsservice on June 3, 2006. The article’s first sentencestated: “Two Chinese mathematicians have put thefinal pieces together in the solution to a puzzle thathas perplexed scientists around the globe for morethan a century.” Cao characterized the barrage ofmedia attention to his work with Zhu as “overwhelming”.Some of the news articles were translatedinto English and posted on the Web. In thosearticles, the achievements of Cao and Zhu, both ofwhom are Chinese, are emphasized, while theachievements of Perelman are mentioned in a lessprominent way. In one story from the Xinhua newsagency, which appeared on June 21, 2006, the nameof Perelman does not even appear. The coveragebegan after Yau held a news conference in Beijingon June 3, 2006, in which he announced the workof Cao and Zhu. Yau said that he was misquotedin some of the media accounts and does notendorse what is said there. On June 20, 2006, hepresented a public lecture on the subject at theMorningside Center of Mathematics at the ChineseAcademy of Sciences in Beijing, the slides ofwhich are available on the center’s website athttp://www.mcm.ac.cn/Active/yau_new.pdf.
Doling Out the Prizes
With so many players, who will get credit for theproof of these monumental results? This is not asimple question. Often in mathematics credit fora result goes to the person who came up with thedecisive ideas that really made the proof work,even if that person never wrote up a completeproof. As a historical example, Robion Kirby of theUniversity of California, Berkeley, pointed toThurston’s orbifold theorem. Thurston describedthis result in a 1982 article in the Bulletin of the AMS[Thurston], using an argument that Kirby characterizedas “definitely sketchy”. The orbifold theoremcovers the Geometrization Conjecture whenthere is a discrete group acting on the threemanifoldwith fixed points, and this covers a lot ofcases, although not the Poincaré Conjecture. Aftermore than a dozen years had passed without acomplete proof, Kirby added the orbifold theoremto his well-known problem list in topology and declaredit to be an open question. Two differentgroups of mathematicians independently producedcomplete proofs of the theorem (one group wasDaryl Cooper, Craig Hodgson, and Steven Kerckhoff,and the other was Michel Boileau, Bernhard Leeb,and Joan Porti). “This was a lot of work, somepieces of Thurston’s sketch were improved, and thecommunity honors their work,” Kirby said. “But itis acknowledged that this is Thurston’s theorem.”
The mathematical world is waiting to find outwhether Perelman will receive a Fields Medal forhis work. The traditional rule followed by theFields Medal committees is that a recipient mustnot be over forty in the year in which the medal isgiven. Perelman turned forty in June 2006. Somebelieve that, even disregarding the Poincaré andGeometrization Conjectures, Perelman may havedone enough to deserve a Fields Medal. “WhatPerelman’s work says about singularity developmentin Ricci flow is an enormous advance that initself would make him a serious candidate for aFields Medal,” Morgan said.
The Poincaré Conjecture is one of the CMI’sseven Millennium Prize Problems, which were announcedin 2000. Until Perelman’s work, there wereno serious solutions proposed to any of the problems,so no prizes have yet been given. The prizerules state that a proposed solution must be publishedin “a refereed journal of worldwide repute”
and that this published solution must be out fortwo years before the CMI will consider awarding aprize. The rules are worded in such a way that theperson considered for the prize need not be the authorof the published solution, noted James Carlson,president of the Clay Mathematics Institute.“The fact that Perelman pursued an unorthodoxroute and posted [his papers] on the arXiv and did not submit them to a journal is not itself an obstacle”
to him receiving the prize, Carlson said. Atthe appropriate time, he said, the Clay Institute willconsider all the available materials and make ajudgment about whether the proof of Poincaré iscorrect. Only after that will it consider giving theprize. One question the Clay Institute faces iswhether to give the prize solely to Perelman or toinclude others as joint recipients—perhaps Hamilton?Carlson said it would be premature for himto speculate on such possibilities.
But no doubt the mathematical world will continueto speculate and to discuss the extraordinary saga of Perelman’s work. One thing is clear: Perelmanhas made an enormous contribution to thefield. Many of the things he did—not submiting hiswork to a journal, not lecturing much, completelyshunning the limelight—are not easy to understand.“Perelman is a very talented and unusual individual,and this is the route that he has chosen,”
Carlson remarked. “I think the most importantthing is that he wrote those three papers and heposted them on the arXiv, and that has given mathematiciansa great gift and lots of new ideas andthings to think about.”
评论 (0)