[注:最近一个时期来发生的“丘成桐-田刚之争”是当前中国数学界的一个大事件,牵动了海内外诸多学生学者,其中不乏世界级“名角”“大腕”,当前学界正是云腾雾起,观者远不只是数学精英;事主虽然多为华人,然而,拳脚早已飞响出北大、浙大之外——哈佛、MIT、斯坦福、UCLA、中文大学尤见刀光剑影。其争论涉及“学问、为人、问政、做官、爱国、腐败、吃喝、开车”;总之,极为广泛。对各路学人寻思“学界谜精”不无启发。《八阕》对此进行了系列跟踪,收集了散发在各论坛(北大、浙大、北京科技、晨兴、科技教育等)的论证和讨论,有当前当事人的言论,也有一些历史溯源。对这一争论感兴趣的朋友,可以使用八阕的消息搜索功能,键入“丘成桐”或者“田刚”等关键字,找到大批相关讨论。陈[省身]大师仙去不久,江湖便起纷争,孰知是祸是福?——八阕编辑]
加州大学Santa Cruz分校数学教授Andrey Todorov说Princeton的Nadal说田刚是个很不诚实的人(very dishonest person),同时说田刚看过Andrey Todorov自己的论文预印本,意思是帮了田刚加入Andrey Todorov的研究(现在叫Tian-Todorov)
Andrey Todorov评价田刚是能干的数学家,但是说Kazdan认为田刚一生证明的东西都是预料到的。原文如下:
The history about the proof that the moduli space of CY manifolds is unobstructed. In 1980 Bogomolov proposed a method how to prove that the moduli space of varieties with canonical class zero is unobstructed. His arguments are beautiful and work only for Hyper-Kahler. I started to work on the problem that the moduli space of CY manifolds is unobstructed in 1986. The same year I published a preprint in MPI. In December of 1986 I received a letter from Tian stating that he had discovered the same xxxxula, which now is called Tian-Todorov Lemma.
In 1992 during my visit to Princeton I met Nadal (a student of Yum-Tung). He explained me that Tian is very dishonest person. He told me that Tian knew about my preprint before he wrote the paper about the moduli of CY. Nadal told me that he saw Tian to study my preprint in Harvard.
My paper contains more results. Unfortunately Cumrum Vafa and his authors called Tian gauge one of my observations in the paper. I told Cumrum about it and he put the reference to my MPI preprint of 1986 in his paper with Bershadky, Cecotti and Ouguri.
Once Kazhdan asked me what I think about Tian. I told him that I think that he is a capable mathematician. Then Kazdan told me that Tian never in his life proved any Theorem that was not known or expected.
Yours,
Andrey Todorov
附:前八回合总结
丘派2分是李骏、洪家兴等澄清事件得一分,郑绍远声明澄清事件得一分,丘成桐用自己的名字指出国内学风问题,得1分,,可是从北大反指控老看,丘成桐做人还是有毛病,负0.5分,丘成桐夸大的田刚/庆杰的论文是剽窃,负0.5分。
北大是安金鹏为田刚说明一个事件得0.5分(因为不是丘成桐指控的事件,所以不是一分,是网上攻击田刚的旁支)
sgy为田刚/庆杰澄清丘成桐的抄袭指控,得0.5分,因为sgy不用自己的真名、不用自己的数学家资历来明确作证,所以没有得一分,何况这事情比较明显是丘成桐过分了。
北大、田刚(匿名)只攻击丘,对自己的问题一个不谈,专门抹黑对手,北大还正式开大会来抹黑对手,负0.5分这种做法,负一分
北大丁伟岳自我承认再次向中国行政上级禁止丘成桐在中国媒体出现,这样的政治手腕,完全败坏了北大民主传统,负一分。
所以北大总分负一分。
细节参见:
《丘成桐-田刚大争进入八回合:田派公开回应》
http://www.popyard.org/cgi-mod/npost.cgi?cate_id=0&page=1&num=54466
评论 (0)