原题:Joerg Enders found mistakes in Xi-Ping Zhu’s paper
Zhu Xi-Ping (with Bing-Long Chen) posted a revision of the article ``Ricci flow with surgery on four-manifolds with positive isotropic curvature” (arXive DG 0504478) on May 30, 2005. In this article, they claimed that they provided all necessary details for Sections 1-5 of Perelman’s second paper. Moreover, they also claimed that they extended some results of Perelman to four manifolds with positive isotropic curvature. In addition, they remarked that their results were parallel to the upcoming paper of H.-D Cao and Xi-Ping Zhu, published in Asian Journal of Mathematics very recently.
图:Joerg Enders
Unfortunately, Joerg Enders, a graduate student at Michigan State University, found a serious mistake
in Chen-Zhu’s paper mentioned above. Chen-Zhu acknowledged the gap on page 5-6 of the recent revision, dated June 4, 2006, see web address `` http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/math/pdf/0504/0504478.pdf”.
In his new revision of June 4, 2006, Chen-Zhu claimed that they were able to repair the gap by a different argument.
However, new Corollary 2.4 in the most recent revision still has a mistake. The new Corollary 2.4 concerns the limit of singular spaces (Alexandrov spaces). Chen-Zhu claimed that the limit of Alexandrov spaces must be a splitting space, i.e., contains a length-minimizing geodesic line. There are counter-examples to new Corollary 2.4, due to the following fact.
The diameter of the unit tangent cone of a singular space at a point could be smaller than \pi. Thus, the singular limit space does not necessarily have a line, i.e., the limit of singular Alexandrov spaces may not split.
Chen-Zhu overlooked the above fact about the singular spaces (Alexanderov spaces), and hence made a new mistake in the new revision.
The article mentioned above is the third revision of Chen-Zhu’s paper.
It remains to see whether or not Xi-Ping Zhu carried over his mistakes to his upcoming joint paper with H. D. Cao
评论 (0)