来客网

老邱鼓动下,中国老记们丢大人了

声明:本文转载自 「八阕--科技时空」, 或因排版与篇幅原因进行过编辑,内容未经本站独立核实,不代表本站立场、观点或建议。 如涉及版权问题,请联系我们,核实后立即删除。 [ 免责声明 ]

相关新闻《新一期 AMS Notice:庞加莱不再猜想?[英文]》

http://www.popyard.com/cgi-mod/post.cgi?cate=0&page=1&num=21724&r=0

老美的报道还是客观一些,比起新华社的报道怎么连人家perelman提都不提?邱鼓动能力也太强了。里面提到了老多牛人Perelman, Hamilton, Morgan and Tian, Milnor, Yau, Cao-Zhu, 等等,不过跟老邱不一伙的Morgan 和 Milnor,似乎国人并不知道。国人大概只知道30%贡献的Cao-Zhu,50%贡献的Hamilton,还有少数人知道仅25%贡献的可怜的俄国人Perelman,当然还知道所有牛人的总指导人-Yau.

人家没太明说,但是说的还是比较清楚的,真希望他们说的是假的,中国人真的漏一脸

In late April 2006 the Asian Journal of Mathematicsannounced on its website the upcomingpublication of the paper by Cao and Zhu, “A completeproof of the Poincaré and GeometrizationConjectures—Application of the Hamilton-Perelmantheory of the Ricci flow”. The announcementincluded the paper’s abstract, which states in full:“In this paper, we give a complete proof of thePoincaré and the geometrization conjectures. Thiswork depends on the accumulative works of manygeometric analysts in the past thirty years. Thisproof should be considered as the crowningachievement of the Hamilton-Perelman theory ofRicci flow.” The 330-page paper appeared in printin the June 2006 issue of the Asian Journal. Theissue has not been made available electronically onthe journal’s website and is available only as aprinted paper publication. The Cao-Zhu article didnot circulate as a preprint, but the work presentedthere was described in Zhu’s lectures at Harvardduring the 2005–2006 academic year.

Some have noted the short amount of time betweenthe submission date for the Cao-Zhu paper,December 12, 2005, and the date when it was acceptedfor publication, April 16, 2006, and wondered whether such an important paper of over 300 pages could have been refereed in a serious way.In a May 2006 interview, Yau, who is one of the editors-in-chief of the Asian Journal, said that theman uform had been around for a year, but “wehave been very careful not to distribute it, to makesure everything is right before it is in print.” Askedwhether the paper had been refereed in the usualway, Yau said that it had and remarked that theAsian Journal has very high standards.

Although not enough time has yet passed for the Cao-Zhu paper to have been subjected to muchscrutiny by the mathematical community, the paper became widely known because of coverage aboutit in the Chinese press during June 2006. “Chinese Mathematicians Solve Global Puzzle” read the headlineof an article that appeared on the Xinhua newsservice on June 3, 2006. The article’s first sentencestated: “Two Chinese mathematicians have put thefinal pieces together in the solution to a puzzle thathas perplexed scientists around the globe for morethan a century.” Cao characterized the barrage ofmedia attention to his work with Zhu as “overwhelming”.Some of the news articles were translatedinto English and posted on the Web. In thosearticles, the achievements of Cao and Zhu, both ofwhom are Chinese, are emphasized, while theachievements of Perelman are mentioned in a lessprominent way. In one story from the Xinhua newsagency, which appeared on June 21, 2006, the nameof Perelman does not even appear. The coveragebegan after Yau held a news conference in Beijingon June 3, 2006, in which he announced the workof Cao and Zhu. Yau said that he was misquotedin some of the media accounts and does notendorse what is said there. On June 20, 2006, hepresented a public lecture on the subject at theMorningside Center of Mathematics at the ChineseAcademy of Sciences in Beijing, the slides ofwhich are available on the center’s website athttp://www.mcm.ac.cn/Active/yau_new.pdf.

评论 (0)