来客网

曹-朱之庞加莱猜想证明并不完整[英文]

声明:本文转载自 「科技时空」, 或因排版与篇幅原因进行过编辑,内容未经本站独立核实,不代表本站立场、观点或建议。 如涉及版权问题,请联系我们,核实后立即删除。 [ 免责声明 ]

There are some reservations on the recent paper of Cao-Zhu on the complete proof of the Poincare-Thurston conjecture, which was recently published in Asian Journal of Mathematics.

One of the concerns was that Section 6 of Cao-Zhu’s paper used a controversial preprint of Bing-Long Chen and Xi-Ping Zhu posted on Arxiv. Math.dg/0504478. Another concern is that Cao-Zhu used an un-verified claim of Shioya-Yamaguchi appeared on Math Ann., volume 133 (2005) 133-150.

Since Thurston’s geometric conjecture implies Poincare conjecture, there are two approaches to prove the Poincare conjecture. The first approach was to prove Poincare conjecture only, which was outlined by Perelman’s first and third paper, together with the work of Colding-Minicozzi (cf. J. AMS, vol 18(2005) 561-569). Another approach was to solve Thurston geometrization classification conjecture entirely, which was outlined in the second paper of Perelman.

Kleiner-Lott’s notes took the second approach, so did Cao-Zhu.

Theorem 7.4 of Perelman’s second paper played an essential role in the second approach, for which Perelman previously planned to post a separated paper devoted to the proof of Theorem 7.4.

However, two Japanese mathematicians Shioya and Yamaguchi jumped in. They thought that they could prove a result stronger than Perelman’s Theorem 7.4. Perelman rebuked and pointed out some errors in the earlier version of Shioya-Yamaguchi’s paper. At the end, Shioya and Yamaguchi published a detailed proof of a result weaker than Perelman’s Theorem 7.4, see above. In the appendix of their paper, Shioya and Yamaguchi claimed that their proof could lead a theorem stronger than Perelman’s Theorem 7.4. However, Shioya and Yamaguchi did not supply the detail of the proof of Perelman’s collapsing theorem 7.4, up to today.

There are some essential difference between what Shioya-Yamaguchi actually proved and what Perelman needed in his program. Roughly speaking, Shioya-Yamaguchi only dealt the case of globally collapsed manifolds, while Perelman considered the general case of locally collapsed manifolds under an upper curvature condition.

In order to apply Shioya-Yamaguchi’s techniques to Perelman’s general case, additional efforts are required. Basically, one has to consider spaces with controlled boundaries or controlled infinity. Thus, Perelman’s upper curvature condition (3) is needed to obtain a nice decomposition of a manifold (a good chopping in the sense of Cheeger-Gromov). Shioya-Yamaguchi claimed that they could drop Perelman’s upper scaled curvature condition (3), and obtain a good decomposition of a manifold (to get a good family of domains with controlled second fundamental forms).

Experts would have difficulties to carry out Shioya-Yamaguchi’s sketched proof of Perelman’s Theorem 7.4 without Perelman’s condition (3).

In short, Shioya-Yamaguchi did a sloppy job related to Perelman’s theorem 7.4. Both Kleiner-Lott and Cao-Zhu directly quote Shioya-Yamaguchi’s claimed ``proof” of Perelman’s theorem 7.4. Therefore, the proof of Poincare-Thurston conjecture remains to be completed in detail.

Cao-Zhu’s claimed complete proof of Poincare-Thurston conjecture turned out to be incomplete.

评论 (0)